Comparison · All comparisons

Protokol Lab
vs MyFitnessPal.

The legacy calorie counter — massive food database, generic use case.

What MyFitnessPal does well

  • Enormous crowdsourced food database — almost any food you can think of has at least one entry.
  • Barcode scanning and recent/favorite food workflows are mature and fast.
  • Recipe builder and saved meals cover common cooking patterns.
  • Integrations with most smart scales, fitness trackers, and fitness apps.

Where MyFitnessPal falls short for GLP-1 users

  • Zero awareness of GLP-1 pharmacology. No dose tracking, no half-life curves, no symptom overlay.
  • Daily calorie resets fight the GLP-1 appetite cycle — low-appetite days read as "under goal" failures.
  • Food database has significant duplicate and inaccurate entries from the crowdsourced model.
  • Aggressive freemium friction: features move behind paywall, ad load increased, macro editing gated.

Feature matrix

FeatureMyFitnessPalProtokol Lab
Dose tracking with half-life curves ✗✓
Rolling 7-day calorie budget ✗✓
Food barcode scanning ✓✓
Food database size
MFP has a multi-year lead on crowdsourced breadth
Very largeLarge
Symptom severity 0–10 scale ✗✓
Custom compounds (user-defined) ✗✓
Agentic AI assistant ✗✓
Ads in free tier ✓✗
Data export (full history, free) ◐✓
Pricing Free + ~$19.99/moFree + $6.58/mo

Use MyFitnessPal if…

You're not on a GLP-1, you want the largest possible food database, and you're okay with daily calorie resets and a generic weight-loss frame.

Use Protokol Lab if…

You're on Tirzepatide, Semaglutide, Ozempic, Wegovy, Mounjaro, Zepbound, or a compounded peptide and you want a tracker that treats your week as a week — not seven separate days where four of them look like you failed. Plus dose tracking, symptom tracking, and an AI that reads it all together.

FAQ

Can I just use MyFitnessPal and ignore the GLP-1 stuff?

You can, and many people do at first. The problem shows up around week 2: you have three 900-calorie days from peak suppression and two 2,400-calorie rebound days, and MyFitnessPal flags four of seven days as failures even though your weekly total is perfect. That pattern is why people switch.

Is Protokol Lab cheaper than MyFitnessPal Premium?

Yes. MyFitnessPal Premium runs around $19.99/month. Protokol Lab Premium is $9.99/month monthly, or $79/year ($6.58/mo effective) — roughly a third of MFP Premium, with GLP-1-specific features MFP does not offer.

Does Protokol Lab have a food database as big as MyFitnessPal?

No — MyFitnessPal's database has a multi-year lead on breadth. Protokol Lab's food library is large and growing, with barcode scanning, custom foods, and an AI that can pull nutrition for unusual items via web search. For 95% of everyday meals you'll find what you need.

Can I import my MyFitnessPal history?

MyFitnessPal offers a data export that Protokol Lab can parse into your food log and weight history. Dose history has to be re-entered since MFP does not track it.

Does Protokol Lab have ads?

No. The free tier is ad-free. Revenue comes from Premium subscriptions, not ad sales.

Visit MyFitnessPal ↗

See Protokol Lab for yourself.

Real data. No signup required.

Other comparisons